Tolerance for Elizabeth Warren’s Fake News
The network news divisions boast about how much they care about the truth and then rage against President Trump when he calls them makers of “fake news.” But when it comes to the politicians they adore, especially those they wish would run for president, the truth takes a back seat.
Exhibit A right now is Elizabeth Warren, who falsely claimed in a professional directory to be descended from Cherokee Indians, so as to be listed as a minority when she was hired as a professor. When Trump makes fun of her by calling her “Pocahontas,” the networks get oh so upset and call it a “racial slur.” But they don’t seem to care one iota about how American Indians feel regarding white people who take on a fake minority identity.
The story broke during Warren’s 2012 campaign against then-Sen. Scott Brown in Massachusetts. In May, liberal writer Garance Franke-Ruta summarized for The Atlantic: “the progressive consumer advocate has been unable to point to evidence of Native heritage except for an unsubstantiated thirdhand report that she might be 1/32 Cherokee. Even if it could be proven, it wouldn’t qualify her to be a member of a tribe.” So a Senate candidate was committed a race-based fraud. CBS broadcast programs touched the story once.
In June, Nancy Cordes reported that Warren said her relatives told her of her Cherokee background. Then, Cordes aired this double-lie sound bite from Warren: “I know my family’s heritage. It’s also been clear from the very beginning that I never got any special breaks from it.” If she knew her family heritage, why couldn’t she document it? Why invent the heritage if not to derive advantages from it?
Cordes then neatly bundled and threw away the entire controversy: “Recent polls show most voters in Massachusetts don’t think Warren’s heritage is a big deal,” she said. Those “truth” tellers implied that we shouldn’t get too disturbed by a little lie to get hired at an Ivy League.
NBC also touched it just once that year, on the “Today” show on Oct. 2, after David Gregory moderated a Brown-Warren debate. He asked Warren, “Do you consider yourself a minority?” She replied: “I listed myself as Native American. … It’s part of who I am.” Gregory later asked her: “Are you hiding something?” Again, Warren lied: “No, I’m not. I never used it for college, for law school or to get a job.” Over and out.
Just try to put those sentences together: “I listed myself as Native American in a professional directory … and I never used it to get a job.”
In response, the “facts first” media simply walked away. To address this honestly was to call her a liar. PolitiFact has only seven rulings on Warren, four “Mostly True” and three “Half True.” The site has never addressed this lie.
By the way, ABC never covered this controversy in 2012.
When Trump called her Pocahontas in 2016, the networks brought out the weasel words. ABC’s Mary Bruce reported, “Friday night, Trump hitting hard, attacking her for once claiming she was Native American.” Once claiming? She has claimed it for years.
It’s disturbing, all right. It’s disturbing that Warren routinely gets a pass on her lies. These are the benefits the liberal media hand out to their favorites.
L. Brent Bozell III is the president of the Media Research Center.