Trending
With the 2023 Iowa legislative session officially in the rearview mirror, the three elected officials who represent Marshall County -- Rep. Sue Cahill (D-Marshalltown), Rep. Dave Deyoe (R-Nevada) and Sen. Jeff Edler (R-State Center) -- took time to reflect on the bills that passed, the bills they wish would've passed and the general direction of the state in recent interviews with the T-R.
Cahill: Another tough session for Dems
Cahill, who ran for re-election unopposed in 2022 and represents the city of Marshalltown along with the southeast quadrant of Marshall County, is one of the last remaining elected Democrats who resides outside of Iowa's major metropolitan areas, and she admitted that her list of highlights for the 2023 session was much shorter than her list of lowlights.
With the Republicans holding the governor's office along with substantial majorities in both the House and the Senate, they were able to advance many of their top legislative priorities this year, and Cahill, a retired longtime educator who worked for the Marshalltown Community School District, expressed particularly opposition to the bill that will provide Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) for students who wish to attend private schools.
Cahill felt the GOP was out to "undermine" public education during the session with bills like the Students First Act and the Parents Bill of Rights, and she believes they made a lot of progress on the goal. While she heard the arguments about parental choice for families that may not otherwise be able to afford to send their children to non-public schools, she contended the Students First Act only helps a select few at the expense of many.
"We know that kids with disabilities, with behavior issues, with parents who might not meet the moral code of a private school are not going to be admitted into those private schools, so that's a real concern," she said. "So we talk about parental choice, but it's only for a few. And we are going to be handing out taxpayer money to people who have successfully managed paying for their private schools over the years."
Citing what she felt was the "contradictory" nature of the Republican legislative priorities, she also wondered why the guidelines on the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) had been tightened despite millions of dollars being given away for private school scholarships.
"(Recipients) have to prove (their eligibility) down to the last nickel and dime, and it's gonna be burdensome for them to do that," Cahill said.
She also discussed changing societal norms and attempts to remove certain books and lessons that include topics like gender identity and sexuality from schools, arguing "it's not the 1950s anymore" and families now look different than they did then.
"I think that this is imported, and I feel it is a power play by the majority party and a select few politicians who are on the extreme side of this culture war," Cahill said.
Nevertheless, she did mention a few positive developments including a recent bill designed to provide property tax relief for veterans, seniors and other individuals on fixed incomes.
"I do have a caveat on that, though. The tax bill is great, but the fact that we didn't fully fund K-12 education and that we pulled some funding from our cities and counties and combined some of their levies, I'm really concerned that we're just playing a shell game," Cahill said. "And cities, counties and some of the other entities may have to raise their levies to meet their needs. So I'm optimistic that this will help our seniors and our vets. I will wait and see how it affects our middle class folks who are enjoying homeownership, and I hope that it truly does affect and lower everyone's property taxes. But I'm a little skeptical."
And while she's still opposed to a bill that loosens labor restrictions for teenagers, she said work was done to make it better through bipartisan effort to ensure that 14 and 15-year-olds were treated differently than 16 and 17-year-olds.
Deyoe: Plenty of progress on taxes
Deyoe has served in the Iowa House since 2007, but he gained some new territory this year due to redistricting and picked up the western half and the northeast quadrant of Marshall County along with most of Story County outside of the city of Ames. When asked for a few of his personal highlights, he noted the private school scholarship bill, property tax reform, a cap on noneconomic damages in medical malpractice lawsuits and the reorganization and consolidation of state agencies from 37 down to 16.
He specifically mentioned the tort reform bill and the fact that so many rural hospitals have lost their OB-GYN services because, in Deyoe's words, doctors are "scared to death" of getting sued and going broke. Deyoe called the property tax package, which amounts to a reduction of about $100 million, a "good start," but he still hopes it will expand beyond seniors and veterans to affect everyone in the future. Property taxes are set at the local level, but the state legislature has passed bills restricting how much they can be increased on a year-to-year basis.
"We've actually chipped away at property tax increases for years. Ever since I've been there, there's been small improvements, but a lot of times it just feels like you're just reducing the rate of the increases," he said. "Of course, this year, a lot of people are noticing the assessments."
He would also like to see further reductions on income taxes and the utilization of state money to provide property tax relief. On the agricultural front, Deyoe, a farmer by trade, said he was disappointed that his bill to put money into the grain indemnity fund and eliminate a tax on grain elevators didn't make it to the governor's desk this year, but he plans to bring it back during next year's session.
Although he initially opposed a private school scholarship bill introduced last year, Deyoe said he came around on the most recent version because he didn't felt it would take money away from public schools.
"It actually just adds money to the whole system, and for that reason, it is more expensive, but I felt like it's money going towards the education of our kids. We've provided more money for public schools and more money for private schools this year, and I think it should help upgrade the education system across the board in the state," he said. "I think it'll have a positive impact on education for K-12 education."
Another bill that Deyoe said didn't receive as much attention but may go down as "the most important" of the session will provide liability protections for teachers who discipline students, which he hopes will help them regain control of their classrooms.
Despite some of the controversy it generated, especially in the national media, Deyoe reflected proudly on the work he did with regard to the youth employment bill allowing teenagers to work later hours and serve alcohol at some restaurants.
"We needed to allow some ability for teenagers to be able to, it's beneficial for them to be able to work. If they can be out until 10:00 at night in sports activities and extracurricular activities, then why can't they work until 9:00?" he asked. "Not all kids are athletes."
Edler: Welfare reform a major step
Edler was heavily involved in several marquee bills that passed during the session, including the SNAP benefit modifications and a ban on gender-affirming care for minors before they turn 18. He said welfare reform had been a priority of his for some time, and the goal is to ensure that only those who truly need the benefits receive them.
"The reality is we want to make sure (that) those individuals are eligible for SNAP get it, and the people who don't need it shouldn't have it," he said. "It's pretty simple and straightforward... You can't be sitting on a large sum of money in a bank account or in assets and still expect the taxpayer to feed you. That's just not right."
Like Deyoe, Edler was happy to see more action on keeping property taxes in check in light of the recent assessments.
"If (local governments) do raise the tax, they still have that ability, but they're gonna have to do it in a highly transparent hearing process to where individuals, if they're engaged, they're gonna have a good input," he said.
On the educational front, Edler believes the Students First Act will help both public and private schools succeed and become productive adults in the Iowa workforce. He noted the new money still being allocated to public schools as evidence that they will not be harmed by the legislation.
"There's no one right way of doing it, and I think that's kind of what's hampered us in the past," he said. "I support public education. I always will, but for some kids that's just not the right form. And we shouldn't be penalizing kids just because they don't perform in a public education system."
In a series of moves that mirrored other conservative states across the country, the Republican-controlled House and Senate passed several bills aimed at giving parents more say in their childrens' education, restricting curriculum and books related to gender identity and sexuality in grades K-6 and banning gender affirming care for anyone under the age of 18. Edler said the changes were "common sense" as kids at that age often change their minds and revert back to their original genders in the end.
"If you start planting seeds, that can have a very detrimental effect," he said. "We're just saying we're gonna let kids be kids. We shouldn't have medical people trying to tell them they should do irreversible harm to their bodies when the reality is 80 percent of those minors revert back to their original birth sex. So why would we allow them to essentially mutilate themselves, become sterile and be tied to a lifelong medical intervention? That's nonsense."
As for some of the lesser-known moves he felt deserved more attention, Edler highlighted work on an update to the Certificate of Need (CON) process for healthcare providers, which he hopes will make it through the House next year in an attempt to control health care costs.
Heading into the 2024 session, some of Edler's top priorities will be Medicaid reimbursement rates and helping Iowans work their way out of public assistance programs.
"We just need to keep moving forward in a responsible manner. That's what people are expecting us to do," he said. "We're gonna keep hammering away and try and continue to push Iowa into the upper echelon of places to live, and we can do that by holding taxes lower and having a good place to live."