Breaking News
Todays News

Iowa Supreme Court holds oral arguments at Toledo’s Wieting Theater

By Michael D. Davis 4 min read
T-R PHOTO BY MICHAEL D. DAVIS The seven justices of the Iowa Supreme Court made the Wieting Theater stage in Toledo their court during oral arguments held on Tuesday, Nov. 10.

TOLEDO -- On Tuesday, Nov. 10, the Iowa Supreme Court came to town to hold oral arguments at the Wieting Theater in Toledo. It was a real case, a real situation, and oral arguments involve attorneys making their case to the court, referencing legal facts and clarifying their points and side of things.

The court was hearing arguments regarding a murder case, State of Iowa V. Duval Tremont Walker, Jr. The case summary in the pamphlet provided read as follows.

"Duval Tremont Walker, Jr. appealed his convictions for first-degree murder and going armed with intent arising from a 2023 St. Patrick's Day confrontation in a Cedar Rapids bar. Walker argued that the district court improperly denied his challenges for cause to two prospective jurors exposed to news coverage and erred in refusing an imperfect-self-defense instruction. The Iowa Court of Appeals ordered a new trial based on the district court's refusal to strike a juror who knew of Walker's prior guilty plea to being a felon in possession of a firearm. The Iowa Supreme Court granted the State's application for further review."

Those in attendance listened intently to the lawyers and judges speak back and forth about bias and other factors with the case. After roughly an hour, the arguments had concluded, and the court opened up to the public for general questions. Several questions were asked, including a few that the judges hadn't heard before. The queries ranged from whether the judges had to purchase their own robes to how fervently they argued amongst each other over cases.

When asked if they had cases that stuck with them, Chief Justice Susan Larson Christensen spoke about how her time in the juvenile courts affected her.

"Every time I speak to a school, kids always want to know, 'Oh, tell me the blood, guts, and gore, and all that business," she said. "And in all honesty, I usually tell them about vehicular homicide or something like that, cause everyone can understand drunk driving, but I never tell them the truth, which is horrific things have happened to children in the state of Iowa. It’s too ugly. So, for me, as a trial court judge, that tops anything I've ever done on this court."

Justice David May spoke about why they take their show on the road to communities such as Toledo. The Court held a similar oral argument event in Marshalltown back in 2024.

"We do it because we're trying to get out into the community and see and be seen and sort of open up our process so we're not hidden away in Des Moines all the time. It’s energizing for us, and we get a lot of good feedback from local folks," he said. "So, we try to do it three or four times a year, and we're trying to rotate around the state. So we try to find communities that have a stage or auditorium where we can have good facilities, and it’s been great to be here tonight because we had a really great turnout, and the community's been very welcoming."

The crowd was filled with locals who hold prominent positions in the community, including both Tama County Attorney Brent Heeren and Toledo City Attorney Michael Marquess.

"I was glad to see such a great turnout from the community and appreciate the Supreme Court selecting Toledo for its Court on the Road Session. The case was very interesting, and the Justices were gracious with their time," Marquess said.

The night was filled with judicious intrigue and delight as all in attendance enjoyed themselves and maybe even learned a thing or two.

Starting at /week.