Breaking News
Columnists

Why ask taxpayers to inflate another golden parachute?

By Randy Evans 4 min read
Randy Evans

Iowa governments sometimes seem to have as many parachutes as an Army airborne unit.

The former school superintendent in Sioux City. The chief academic officer in the Des Moines public schools. The police chief in Cedar Rapids.

Now, Matt Degner is the latest high-ranking official to strap on one of these taxpayer-financed "golden parachutes" and float gently out the door of the Iowa City Community School District.

On November 10, "by mutual consent," Degner submitted his resignation as executive director of secondary schools in Iowa's third largest district. The school board accepted his resignation. But the board also gave Degner a $90,000 cash going-away gift for reasons that have not been adequately explained.

This was Degner's second resignation from the Iowa City schools in less than a year. In June, he stepped down as superintendent and requested a transfer to the secondary schools position. He had served as superintendent since January 2021.

Both resignations came as the district and its school board struggle to deal with a financial crisis exceeding $45 million. The problem occurred under Degner's leadership, largely out of public view and without proper scrutiny from his bosses on the school board.

As the magnitude of the crisis became public, the board established an outside financial oversight committee, chaired by longtime Iowa City banker Charlie Funk, to help address what Funk described as the "disarray" in the district's accounts.

At a recent committee meeting, the Cedar Rapids Gazette reported, Funk delivered a blunt assessment: "This reflects the ineptitude on the part of former leadership of this district and careless governance from the board. These are strong statements I am making, but they need to be said. The fact are the facts."

That ineptitude included Degner and the chief financial officers he supervised failing to adequately track district revenues and expenses for the past three years. Degner and his assistants also made improper internal transfers of about $10 million between accounts -- without the school board's knowledge or approval -- to cover employee paychecks.

A recently completed and long overdue outside audit found that the district overspent a capital projects fund by about $45 million over four years, also to pay teachers and staff.

The district had gone several years without an annual audit, but top administrators offered no explanation at the time to either the public or the school board for this lack of an independent financial assessment.

Since the financial crisis became public in January, there have been calls for the school board to fire Degner for incompetence or dereliction of his duty. But instead of terminating him last spring when he asked to step aside as superintendent, the board moved him into the secondary schools position.

Now, rather than simply allowing him to leave as other district employees would if they resigned, the board is paying him $90,000 -- half his annual salary in the secondary schools position -- to leave immediately.

That payout nearly equals the salaries of two beginning teachers.

Meanwhile, taxpayers and parents worry about how the district will dig out of its financial hole. They fear some schools may have to close. They wonder how many teachers and support staff will lose their jobs.

Earlier this month, the board decided to consider selling the district's administration building, which board member Mitch Lingo described as "a symbol of overspending." The district bought the building in 2022 for approximately $9 million, then spent another $12 million on improvements.

The use of these "golden parachutes" raises serious questions about accountability and responsible use of tax money, particularly when the departing official's leadership and administrative decisions are the subject of considerable controversy and chaos.

Such payments may be presented as a way to help a school district move beyond its current problems. But taxpayers have a legitimate right to question why their taxes are being used to provide additional compensation to an official whose tenure has been clouded by questionable management decisions and a loss of public confidence.

Whatever the justification the school board offers, the essential question remains: What exactly are the Iowa City taxpayers receiving in return for their $90,000?

When resignation becomes the preferred alternative to dismissal, government employees and the public reasonably wonder whether standards of conduct and personnel policies apply equally to those in the highest positions of authority, as well as to cooks, custodians and classroom teachers.

The Iowa City school board has an obligation to maintain public confidence and demonstrate responsible stewardship of taxpayer resources.

Building that trust requires answers. Handing over a taxpayer-funded check to a controversial official without adequately explaining why it is warranted is no way for public leaders to earn a community's confidence.

Randy Evans is the executive director of the Iowa Freedom of Information Council. He can be reached at DMRevans2810@gmail.com.

Starting at /week.